Welcome to Crossdresser Heaven, a safe and welcoming place for everyone in the crossdresser community.
Join Crossdresser Heaven today to participate in the forums.
Life for a covert dresser can, without doubt, be somewhat challenging. Not necessarily because of the constant fear that your secret persuasion might be discovered, but because of the harm, the upset or confusion you might unleash on those closest to you. Or even those in your wider, historically-secure friendship or work circles, the ones who for years have only known you as a veritable ‘deep-voice-man-guy’. I am reaching a conclusion that dressing has almost an A-class narcotic allure – once tried, always yearned for. The smoothness of the stolen-apple silk is all but soul-enveloping.
So, you dabble along, nudged here, prodded forward there; trying out, getting further entrenched into a secret lifestyle which you try so hard to rationalise, to accept as your ‘norm’. It is undeniably you. Your go-to home base. Your ‘why can’t they just accept it for what it is’ world. But, what of the impact on your SO? What about her - did she know about, or sign up for this? Did she know before she committed to you? That’s a toughie, isn’t it.
It’s an incontrovertible fact that this subject troubles the secret dresser more than anything else in their CD life. In their yin-yang world, the yin is the silky secret pleasure, the yang is worrying about its impact on others; their Significant Other, their soulmate, and most importantly, their wife.
There are as many different outcomes of that dreaded impact as there are wives, and they cover quite the spectrum - from instant divorce, right up to happily sharing her wardrobe with you, and even girls-together shopping trips to keep it beautifully stocked. But in that dark-side place, that no-man’s-land of worry, you constantly wonder, is there a metaphorical bullet with your name on it? And it eats you up. Stealthy is unhealthy, you'd best never forget.
For now though, let’s assume that not only have you dissipated any of the original guilt you might have felt, you have come to a comfortable secrecy, or even a sort of peaceful ‘DADT’ (don’t ask, don’t tell) environment, where you balance your pleasure with your good lady’s tolerance. It works. She’s fine. You’re happy. She is too, sort of, at least on the surface. But then, something changes - a woman’s prerogative, after all. She now does a U-turn: ‘I was sort of accepting, but you know what, I’m not now. Sorry hun, I think we need to…’
And then comes the dreaded bombshell you thought was just for others: the dreaded D-word. Or the one-way street called ‘trial separation’. You probably thought you were in a ‘cake-and-eat-it' world. Now, suddenly and abruptly, you aren’t. The vase is mid-air between her hands and the cold, cold floor.
A friend here on CDH (and, re upcoming pronouns, I have checked; he is happy to be referred to as a male dresser, especially in the following context) has his dressing life quite balanced out, it would seem - and so does his dearly-beloved and tolerant wife of considerable years. Like the proverbial Lady Justice, she may choose to wear a blindfold, she balances the dressing persuasions out on her scales, but she also bears a sword. He wisely keeps one eye on the sword, for if it were ever to get lifted, even slightly, he is certain that “if it came down to my marriage or my dressing, my dressing self would melt like the Wicked Witch of the West”.
I deeply admire his ultimate commitment to his wife. I just wonder though, could I commit to such, even in the face of the ultimate sanction, the about-to-fail marriage? Is the allure of my ‘witch’ too strong?
Could I really control it?
Could you?
It surely begs the question: how wicked is your witch?
Great essay. I can certainly relate as I’m sure many here do. Would the wicked witch melt if faced with an “either/or” from the SO? Depends I suppose on how deeply one was committed to their own feminine soul. Can you not live your life happily without the complete satisfaction of expressing who you really are or would you be left bereft and alone without your SO.
I periodically go through periods of doubt and questioning as to the effect of my desires to present as a woman have on my SO. We recently went through just such an episode when I sat her down and told her I was done, that I was prepared to purge and leave the “witch” buried for good. Her response, “you can’t do that, it’s who you are and I love all of you” (quick end to THAT purge). To me that was an immersion into the level of love possible between two people. But I most certainly understand and appreciate that’s not always the case.
Everyone’s relationship situation is so different, there are so many variables to consider. And unfortunately sometimes the witch has to go permanently underground in order to maintain a lifetime of connections and family. Just the way it is.
For me it’s, long live the witch.
@valentina16 This scenario is played out in nearly every rom-com ever made. The protagonist (usually the fella) meets the person of their dreams, but under some false context. Things are going so well that he can't bring himself to be honest about who he is and eventually, invariably the other person finds out and the ____ hits the fan.
Cue the drama while the fella mopes and despairs and works to convince the gal that, despite this deception, under it all he's really a good person and worthy after all.
In the film this always works out, this story of redemption. That's because it'd be a terribly short and uninteresting story if the fella was just honest from the get go, "Oh, no...you misunderstand, I'm actually the garbage man."
Do not put fear in the driver seat - it never goes where you want to go. I always advise telling your person of interest early, as soon as you think there's a chance this thing might actually develop into something, that's the time. If she 'icks' and moves on, then you've simply saved years of your life and you get the added bonus of crossing her off your list and can start looking for someone more open minded and accepting.
If that moment has passed, then you tell her as early as possible - that means now. Do not wait for the right time, it will never come. You will continue to pile weight on your shoulders and increase the doubt and resentment she will have at your keeping this secret.
But then, something changes - a woman’s prerogative, after all. She now does a U-turn: ‘I was sort of accepting, but you know what, I’m not now. Sorry hun, I think we need to…’
I disagree with the above. This buys into the stereotype that women are flighty and fickle and change their mind on a whim, which is an unfair notion. Humans in general don't behave in this way. I have seen real-life friends experience this before, yes, but they are never just because the spouse woke up that day and chose close-mindedness.
In these situations, there's usually 1 of 2 things that have happened:
- Some new revelation was made by the CD or some previously unrevealed item or act was discovered by the spouse. This clearly erodes the trust level and causes the SO to reconsider. Generally because the CD was afraid to share everything up front and kept things hidden and the future sharing/discovering causes the spouse to panic, wondering where this will all end.
- The SO was never fully on board - she seemed to accept because she wanted to believe, or because she was afraid of losing her partner, or some other reason. However, there has been some trigger that causes her to stop and reconsider that she never wanted to be part of this from the outset. Perhaps she sees a story about some other couple getting torn asunder by this. Regardless of the trigger, she decides she's needs to put a stop to it.
Both of these are communication issues. I feel that if both you and she/he/they are truly open and honest and willing to work through it, I don't see the need for any witches.
I love and lived this article!
My wife was tolerant of it for more then 10 years, then we separated not solely on dressing but it was probably #2. I purged everything and swore off of dressing. The separation ended and she thought (maybe) happily ever after.
Then my depression set in and the urge was to strong. It lasted a few years before I gave in and went back in the closet. Then as usual I left evidence out and got caught. I waited for the D word to fall.
This time I was going to give it to her. Let her find her happiness elsewhere and I would let Jessi be free. Only to have her tell me that she now sees it's not something I can easily give up. So she decided to understand and except. So far things are good and she has spent time with Jessi. I keep reminding her about last time but she reassures me it all is well. I hope it remains that way.
I have realized in my life there needs to be time for my feminine self. My wife has been very accepting since I told her. If that trend ever did reverse though, I can't imagine that I could ever give up this side of me. I think I would develop into a very wicked witch indeed!
Hiding it wasn't healthy!
A beautifully written article Valentina, so eloquently describing the dichotomy we feel between being completely open with our SO and keeping our secret completely to ourselves.For some perhaps maintaining a secret life might heighten the excitement of transformation, but essentially you are living a lie of omission. For me that kind of stress is way to much to bear, especially when engaging in a behavior that is supposed to satisfy a particular need and be pleasurable.
I agree wholeheartedly with Melodee and support full disclosure from the earliest stages of a relationship, or at least as soon after your active CD activity begins. If you do not you are essentially living a lie and effectively imprisoning yourself and your SO in that lie, forcing you both to live in kind of a prison. Not fair to either of you.So I say disclose fully as soon as you can, keep no secrets, answer all questions and don't let the demon of dishonesty damage the most important relationships in your life.
It has worked for me.
Really well said! I think this is a really great topic.
Before we got married, I tried dropping hints to my wife by suggesting I dress up for Halloween, I intentionally left web pages open to some of the crossdressing stores for her to find, and I even placed an order with Victoria's secret, but didn't really get what I wanted, so I asked my wife (girlfriend at the time) to return it for me. You can't really get any more blatant than that, yet she was still shocked when she discovered my stash. Maybe she was just in denial, so I had to tell her straight out, and I tried to emphasize how deep this really runs for me.
I have said it many times. My wife knows, but does not support my crossdressing. This is a don't ask, don't tell type of a situation. I have come to a place in my life where I accept that this is a part of me, and will never change. Just like everyone else here (most likely), I have purged many times and made efforts to "quit" only to have the urge return and eventually, I would go to all the trouble of rebuilding my wardrobe only to purge again down the line. At this point in my life, if my wife gave me an ultimatum, sorry, my witch is too strong.
I would however seek another SO, and going forward I would want to be open and honest about my crossdressing from the get go. There is a part of me that really longs to meet a special woman that would support and even participate in my crossdressing hobby. "Girls together shopping trips" would be a dream come true, but I would also just settle with fashion tips, help with makeup, and girls night at home would be great too. I would still want to keep it just between the two of us, but to be able to do it freely (at home), without having to sneak around seems like it would be a wonderful thing.
Way back, my witch was in conflict with my then wife's hatred of my CD'ing. To still keep in touch with my "angel", I dressed away from home for work or in my office when everyone else had left for the day. That union ended up in divorce around the turn of the century.But not before some early purges etc, so it "would all go away".
Not very long after I separated, I found my new and loving partner, who knows about Caty "but does not want to know". It's a loving DADT relationship and early on, I was so happy I was like a recovered drug addict, I "never touched a drop of CD'ing".
But of course, sooner or later "it all comes back" and these days Caty has a complete femme wardrobe and the extras that go with it. IE Wigs, breast forms, make up etc etc.
So in effect, I put Ms Witch on her broom and sent her packing. My only problem is the problem I have with some minor health issues that prevent me from doing my monthly charity overnight volunteer trips, that allow me to get my "full Caty on"
So I sneak a few hours here and there at home, eg today, when the Boss went to lunch or dress down in my "Comfy" 3m sq storage unit about 30mins from home.
Plus I sleep femme in my own room and bed up the other end of the house.
Caty.
I disagree Valentina,
Witches like these should only go one way, "South to hell". Cos they can sure make life hell for folks like us.
Caty.
My witch 🧙♀️ is well and truly stuck in the closet, my wife has absolutely no idea I'm a crossdresser and I'm sure she would feel betrayed to learn that I've been dressing most of our married life,
This is the only secret I've kept between us and I'm sure it would spell the end of our marriage,
Hugs Roz
I know how you feel Chrissie, it's been hard keeping it a secret so long, many times I've just wanted to say that I'm a crossdresser and i love to wear feminine clothes, it would be wonderful to wear a dress everyday and not be judged,
Hugs Roz X
I have now got to the stage where I realise I've sacrificed too much and denied who I really am. Now it's simple. I tell and they don't like it it's over .
What a great question! I'm definitely in this situation... if she found out, what exactly would she do? Probably very accepting and supportive... or maybe likely to hit me on the head with something very large and solid (that probably used to be known as my left arm...) At the end of the day, I reckon it would have to be K rather than Alice - but I hope like hell that I never have to find out for sure... Final thing: you mention "witches": I recently saw something about a poll about the "Greatest Witch Ever": they had it (in ascending order from third to first) as Alyson Hannigan (Willow Rosenberg in Buffy The Vampire Slayer) Holly Marie Combs (Piper Halliwell in Charmed) and Elizabeth Montgomery (Samantha Stevens in Bewitched.) Think they got the top three entirely right, but surely Holly should have been top and... well, I can't make my mind up regarding who should have been second... What do you reckon? Alice XXX
Just had this conversation, no more than an hour ago, with my wife. She's currently in the "totally intolerant" mindset. Three months ago, I set up a meet-up with another CDer for this Friday. She had no issues with it, but as of late, that's totally changed. She used to tell me that she would leave me only if I transitioned. A week ago, she said that if I ever go to another nightclub, she'll leave. She says that I dress like a slut when I go clubbing & she's worried about guys trying to pick me up. I dress like any other woman. I try to blend in. And, although I like to flirt, I never let it go any further.
Well, this week, she told me that, if I go out on Friday, she'll be very disappointed & upset. This morning, after I read to her some of the advice that other CDH members have given me to work through this, she intimated that I had the green light to go live my life as a woman & that she'd be fine without me in her life.
That's not what I want. Yeah, I want to be a woman, but not without her. She's my whole world. She means everything to me &, if it means the end of Dawn, then that's how it'll have to be. But now, I wonder if these feelings are reciprocal. I guess my witch is not very wicked.
"Do you want to be a woman?"
She spoke the question very quietly in the course of a tense conversation in the kitchen one morning.
It was sprung on me and I'd had no time to prepare.
In retrospect, even if I had had any forewarning, I doubt I would have had the capacity to formulate a decent answer.
For years and years (from our courtship days) and 27 years into our marriage, she had been a consistent ally, weaving my crossdressing into our bedroom play and rejecting gender norms.
That morning I sensed a change. Her tone was hostile and pregnant with reproach.
Three months later she passed. I still hear her questioning tone ringing in my head, nearly eight years.
I had perhaps let "the witch" out too often, or perhaps allowed her into certain off-limits spaces?
I still don't know. Nor can I think of an answer.
Well, DO I want to be a woman?
We-ell, yes. But only in finite installments, I think.
Love,
Katherine