Is an accurate set of answers important for profiles to be helpful?

You must be logged in to participate.
  • Yes
  • No
  • Creator
    Topic
  • #326845
    Falecia McGuire
    Participant
    Registered On: January 11, 2019
    Topics: 6
    Replies: 67
    Has thanked: 49 times
    Been thanked: 346 times

    Please know that I’m not complaining.  I’m just suggesting that we encourage more and better sharing.  Let me say two things:

    • I spent my career in government service, so I get data-forms.
    • I’m a car-nut, so I know how car enthusiasts look at cars.

    What do those things mean?  I know why forced or multiple choice options were chosen for the profile quiz – to limit variables and collect data.  OK, but now that CDH is really a thing, let’s do better and get some useful and accurate answers.  Here’s where the car guy thing comes in.  Today many particularly European cars have transmissions that are called “manual,” but don’t have a clutch.  So, if you’re looking for a true-manual, you have to sort through hundreds of pictures to see if a car has a clutch.  The questions in our profile section give forced responses that are not accurate and, thus, make no sense and make it difficult to assess commonality with fellow members.  If the birthdate indicates you’re 60, you’ve been dressing for 40 years, and your first time was at 50, it doesn’t add up.  If you’re married, your spouse knows, you’re in stealth mode, but you’ve shared with friends, what does that look like?  And, who the heck dresses once a month?  I’m just wondering if we could form a group to decide what in the profile would better serve our desire to make friends.

    FAM

Viewing 23 reply threads
  • Author
    Replies
    • #329401
      Falecia McGuire
      Participant
      Registered On: January 11, 2019
      Topics: 6
      Replies: 67
      Has thanked: 49 times
      Been thanked: 346 times

      Thanks Stephanie,

      I believe your points are well made.  I did not open this topic because I felt people should necessarily share MORE but because so much seemed inaccurate.  I initially suggested that we make the profile more open ended so that members be allowed to share, perhaps anecdotally, so that we got a better picture of their path along their journey.  I wasn’t thinking of a test-of-credibility but more as an opportunity to learn about another traveler.  Number of years and age-when-begun were irrelevant in themselves, but inconsistency was confusing.  I read your profile and found it very helpful in assessing your sincerity.  I came away feeling, “This is a person who gets it!”  Why is that important?  Because, those of us who get it aren’t out to prove anything, change anyone’s mind, or impress anyone with the depth of our fantasies.  We’re here because we want to connect with another human being who shares the frightening, powerful, and even magnificent compulsion to engage in the feminine!  Perhaps, then, the answer is for people to tell some of their story in narration and include time and age only if it aids in the telling.

      FAM

      2 users thanked author for this post.
      • #329438
        Stephanie Kennedy
        Participant
        Registered On: March 15, 2019
        Topics: 6
        Replies: 249
        Has thanked: 741 times
        Been thanked: 666 times

        Hi Felecia I just took to the time to look at my profile there are some inconsistencies. It read i am single . I have not been single for over 38 years. Most information is correct fortunately. I do not even remember filling out that what ever it is to join I just joined blindly and with apprehensive trust. I am not sure now how i even found this place. I think i as invited by a hologram of Vannesa . Not sure now. There was something about what she said that allowed me to trust her. I remember thinking this could be a place were i could relax, not be judged and share a few stories.  I did not even think of it as a place.that could help me. I was in the process of seeking the advice of the so called experts and paying her $150. oo per 45 minute sessions. I could not afford it but i did it anyway. It was that important to me. I even rejected her thoughts when she told me i was a woman in a male body. I was not going for it. She began talking about voice therapy and how it could help me. I was not buying it. Sorry for getting off subject. Now back to CDH . It was easy to join CDH. There was no risk financially. I believe there was a 1 month free trial. It was not intrusive. I felt comfortable sharing information. i really did not believe that some else could think like i did. I just thought i was weird MY point is there are so many of us still out there. I see them and i feel so bad when i see a younger person cruising the ladies dept just as i did.  Maybe it would be best to remind members to update there profile so we can look back at where we started and how far we have come.  There are no real facts about why we have the desire to express our selves in the feminine. We have to go on our feminine instincts and feelings to determine what is safe and not. I know you understand. I do understand other members and there concerns. We all have to remember what it is like to be alone and having a secret that can be so overwhelming and you feel cannot share it with anyone. Then you have arrived at CDH and you are asked to share information about yourself that no one knows about. I mean no one. Then you are ask to tell the truth in different terms of course. When you do not even know the truth you are trying to figure that out.  Now i feel like a old lady. It time to get cute and pretty. Enjoy your femininity It is what makes us special Luv Stephanie

        3 users thanked author for this post.
    • #329318
      Stephanie Kennedy
      Participant
      Registered On: March 15, 2019
      Topics: 6
      Replies: 249
      Has thanked: 741 times
      Been thanked: 666 times

      Hi Felecia i put no. This is a social environment. Not a Government or place of employent.. If some one is inaccurate about there profile it could be they just donot remember and they put anything that is close. Ladies let us not forget this is a friendly, nurturing understanding and very welcoming environment. I see no problem suggesting that members be reminded they first, have a profile and they can update it if they wish and bring a calculator ha ha. I believe CDH is similar to a great restaurant started by a special chef. The Chef’s skills are the mechanics. The passion and love, the joy of cooking for others the feeling the chef creates when setting up the dining room. Just making people FEEL comfortable and relaxed and wanting to share their experience with others by inviting them to a special place to have a bite to eat. The customers of those restaurants even take ownership. It becomes theirs. It is their special place. It does not matter if they are billionaires or simple pipefitters. When you begin to reguest accurate information from anyone we have learned that ALARM BELLS should go off in your head. Now i question what is going to happen to my very private very secret information. Information that has been kept in most cases in my head for most of our lives. You are starting to scare me. Luv Stephanie

       

       

       

      2 users thanked author for this post.
    • #328753
      Diane
      Participant
      Registered On: August 6, 2018
      Topics: 20
      Replies: 177
      Has thanked: 104 times
      Been thanked: 388 times

      I have noticed that quite a few members don’t include their ages in their profiles.  I’m sure that many don’t want to do so because they are shy and worried about being found out and this is perfectly understandable.  Just a thought, but why not have age range options for those who don’t want to give the exact birthdate (e.g. 20- 30; 30-40 etc)?  At least that way other members can at least have a rough idea of the age of the new member.

    • #327889
      Amy Myers
      Participant
      Registered On: February 11, 2019
      Topics: 9
      Replies: 746
      Has thanked: 1446 times
      Been thanked: 1349 times

      Falecia, I answered yes, as it is good to have accurate information about the person. However, as has been mentioned, some are very shy about sharing much info when joining. Also, things change along the way, perhaps months after joining, and folks don’t thing of updating their profile.

      I recently did, and discovered a bit of conflicting information. I did start borrowing my Mom’s things about 12, only it wasn’t till 2018 that I decided to go all out and dress completely en femme.

      All that said, anything that could be done to improve accuracy is a good thing, and those parts someone doesn’t feel comfortable with, can just be left blank.

      Not on topic, but in another part of my life, I’m well known as a “car guy”.

      Amy

      5 users thanked author for this post.
    • #327476
      Wanda Full
      Participant
      Registered On: February 25, 2018
      Topics: 5
      Replies: 31
      Has thanked: 1 time
      Been thanked: 48 times

      Hi Felicia: I agree that the more information someone can provide, the better. However, when joining, many do not want to divulge personal information that may reveal who they are. I encourage gurls to add what they feel comfortabe with and don’t push it. When they become more comfortabe, many add to their profile. Crew and Ambssadors can alo encourage this, but don’t push it. Everyone has their own time. Respect that!

      Hugs, W

    • #327474
      skippy1965 Cynthia
      Ambassador
      Registered On: August 25, 2015
      Topics: 109
      Replies: 1252
      Has thanked: 504 times
      Been thanked: 1238 times

      As most of you know, I greet most every new member and as part of that greeting I encourage folks to complete their profile AND to do an intro post in the new member forum. I get replies from about 40-50% of the folks I greet and many MANY of them (including many who commented here) in their replies area)so happy to get acknowledgement from someone (some for the first time in their lives):b) are often VERY nervous for the same reason; and c) want to explore the site before committing and opening up more about themselves. Many also have a hard time navigating the site or are “technically challenged”.

      While I understand the desire to learn more about folks and I certainly support the idea of ENCOURAGING better completion of the profile page, I would NOT want to make it mandatory. While some folks are comfortable sharing immediately- the will open up over time. I was one of those and I suspect many of you were as well if you think back. Not accepting a friend request from those who haven’t completed much of their profile is fine. But we have an excellent team of ambassadors who review accounts and profiles and pics etc as well as the chat room and I think most of you would agree that most trolls do not last long here at CDH. Each of YOU are part of our watchdog team too. If you see something inappropriate on the site or are approached by someone in an inappropriate manner, all you need do is notify an ambassador and it will be addressed immediately.Many of you have done that in the past and by all means please keep doing so! And DO encourage folks to open up but be patient. Think back to when you were first opening up to others and were terrified.

      Just my opinion!
      Cyn

      • #328949
        Stephanie Flowers
        Ambassador
        Registered On: June 26, 2017
        Topics: 15
        Replies: 3272
        Has thanked: 2518 times
        Been thanked: 3037 times

        Well said…. cyn..

        As for me and many have mentioned. More information about someone through a profile usually results on more replies. Many open up more as their comfortable levels improve.

        This is a wonderful site to many and were always there for anyone whose interested in joining our community.

        Stephanie 🌷

        3 users thanked author for this post.
    • #327459
      Falecia McGuire
      Participant
      Registered On: January 11, 2019
      Topics: 6
      Replies: 67
      Has thanked: 49 times
      Been thanked: 346 times

      Hey Gang,

      Now that this has been out there a few days, I’ve realized that I wasn’t the only one troubled by skimpy and/or contradictory profiles.  While my original intent was not create additional burdens for new or existing members, the wonderful and insightful comments of our stalwarts has brought me around.  I’m now on the side of those who believe that a number of profile entries ought to be required.  Verification is, of course, unrealistic, but we know the BS.  In addition, the burden of completing a profile is underwhelming for those we hope to be vital contributing members.  Most of us want to share because we are eager to learn, listen, and influence.  I already know, for example, that my many years of CD experience has been valuable for many.  I also know that I found comfort in the understanding of others.  In this human condition, credibility IS vital!

      FAM

    • #327298
      Alison Anderson
      Participant
      Registered On: October 15, 2018
      Topics: 1
      Replies: 104
      Has thanked: 53 times
      Been thanked: 294 times

      Even consistency between editing and viewing would be helpful.  When I’m editing, it asks “Has your dressing experience evolved over time? If so, how has it changed?” I answered “Yes.  Yadda yadda yadda.”

      But when viewing it says “Evolution of your dressing.”  Here the “Yes” in front of the text looks out of place.

      1 user thanked author for this post.
    • #327222
      DeeAnn Hopings
      Participant
      Registered On: November 10, 2019
      Topics: 5
      Replies: 305
      Has thanked: 7 times
      Been thanked: 533 times

      I’m 71…

      Trolls aside, I assume that those who don’t fill in much information are worried about security. I don’t know how bullet-proof the CDH site is, but people also need to understand that they need to consistently clear their browser cache so that no one can stumble upon their history. Other, more secure browser options might be Brave, TOR, etc.

      And yes, vacant profiles can be cause for concern…

    • #327092
      T.J. Byron
      Participant
      Registered On: October 18, 2018
      Topics: 0
      Replies: 129
      Has thanked: 228 times
      Been thanked: 346 times

      I will not accept a friendship requist if there are no pictures in photo areas or gallery.
      I need as much info in profiles as possible,so I can relate to area of living, interests,to include CDing .

      Dr.T.J.

       

       

    • #327091
      Diane
      Participant
      Registered On: August 6, 2018
      Topics: 20
      Replies: 177
      Has thanked: 104 times
      Been thanked: 388 times

      I agree wholeheartedly with you Samantha (and the others who have made the same point).  It is so easy to submit a partially completed profile to gain membership of CDH that it is very easy for trolls to join, have a snoop around and even look at private photos which are intended for members only (and which the members concerned might be horrified if they knew that a troll was looking at them 0r, worse still, copying them).

      Yes, it can take a lot of nerve to apply to join CDH.  I mulled it over for quite a while before I joined and was nervous when filling the application out.  A troll doesn’t need to think so hard.  If it is easy to fill a form out in part and still get to join CDH the trolls have achieved their objective.  It must be possible to require every field in an application form to be completed in full before the form can be submitted and, in part that was the reason why I suggested that existing members should be asked to update their profiles.  Legitimate applicants and members respectively wouldn’t mind.  Trolls are less likely to be willing to go so far.

      I don’t want to discourage any prospective crossdresser from joining our community – that is exactly what we want, but I do want us to do as much as we can to protect existing members from trolls.  Requiring an application form to be completed in full would, in my view, be a step in the right direction.

      Diane

    • #327041
      Samantha Roarke
      Ambassador
      Registered On: April 17, 2019
      Topics: 27
      Replies: 482
      Has thanked: 851 times
      Been thanked: 792 times

      So I have seen the coloration between well written profiles that are fully completed, with ladies truly wanting support and real help from the CDH site. The profiles that barely contain a full female name and have no profile information, are almost always some sort of troll figure looking to get their jollies off at our expense. I know this isn’t a deep idea, none the less, still a very true idea. We need to find a way to encourage ladies to fill their profiles out completely as to help us get to know them better and help weed out trolls. Is there a setting that makes one HAVE to fill out the profile 100% or you can’t access the site till you do? Real ladies looking for help and support would have no issue doing that, where a troll would not waste the time to do that as they are lazy creatures. Just a thought….

      Kisses, Samantha Roarke

      • #327062
        Tiffany Alexis
        Founder
        Registered On: March 28, 2019
        Topics: 395
        Replies: 1235
        Has thanked: 1856 times
        Been thanked: 3076 times

        I’ve asked that same question sam. Unfortunately no way to require it. But we can have a generally accepted practice of not accepting friend requests from blank pages….

        She who dares, wins.

        5 users thanked author for this post.
    • #327036
      Peggy Sue Williams
      Participant
      Registered On: June 26, 2019
      Topics: 8
      Replies: 107
      Has thanked: 371 times
      Been thanked: 338 times

      Excellent points you bring up, Falecia, and I am also concerned about many of the things you mention.

      Top of my list is the friendship request.  I get one from someone I have never heard of and have never seen any activity from them on CDH.  So I go to their photos and see nothing.  Then I go to their profile and find it blank!  Why in the world are they requesting friendship?  They are a complete stranger!

      Yes I know, many of us walk a fine line, and for these people, it can be tricky just how much information they want to share.  In the support group I am a member of, we have very strict privacy rules, which are enforced.

      Hugs,

       

      Peggy Sue

    • #326977
      Marianne
      Ambassador
      Registered On: May 20, 2017
      Topics: 11
      Replies: 447
      Has thanked: 253 times
      Been thanked: 655 times

      If I get a friendship request from someone with little or no profile info, I usually send them a private message asking them to tell me about themselves and their intention with our friendship.

      Marianne

    • #326968
      Jennifer Swanson
      Participant
      Registered On: April 20, 2019
      Topics: 39
      Replies: 143
      Has thanked: 2941 times
      Been thanked: 708 times

      I think a more complete set of demographic information might be interesting sociologically, however while I have posted data focused questions, I’m most interested in motivation.  What led you to crossdressing?  Why do you do it?  What do you enjoy most about it?  I love talking to other cds because we are a kind, caring and empathetic community.  I can’t find that anywhere else.

    • #326965
      Tiffany Alexis
      Founder
      Registered On: March 28, 2019
      Topics: 395
      Replies: 1235
      Has thanked: 1856 times
      Been thanked: 3076 times

      Yeah, I won’t approve a friend request on blank or nonsense profiles members. I know many members don’t fill theirs out, but you know who else doesn’t? Trolls. Trolls don’t fill them out. Easiest way to spot one.

      She who dares, wins.

    • #326964
      Sa·man·tha
      Ambassador
      Registered On: January 21, 2018
      Topics: 115
      Replies: 967
      Has thanked: 3486 times
      Been thanked: 2519 times

      I think the questions are fine — but no question you can ask on a profile amounts to a hill of beans if people don’t answer them!!

      At bare minimum, I think everyone ought to give age, gender identity, a general location, and write at least a short bio.

      It would be nice if folks would fill in the rest of the questions too, but these can also be discerned in conversation if you wish, I think

      I understand that people may feel afraid to reveal info.  But I see profile after profile where nothing is filled out.  Nothing.  That doesn’t look very good to me.

      • #326971
        Olivia Livin
        Participant
        Registered On: October 22, 2018
        Topics: 24
        Replies: 1152
        Has thanked: 3325 times
        Been thanked: 1795 times

        I totally agree Sam and Tiffany…

        Stanger danger!!!…maybe

        And even if they’re not trolls, if not interested enough to put in the effort why should we. I just remember how scared I was when I signed up so try  to them the benifit of the doubt, at least temporarily.

        Hopefully some of the new girls will read these responses and take a hint

    • #326911
      Kathryn Lynn
      Participant
      Registered On: October 10, 2016
      Topics: 5
      Replies: 52
      Has thanked: 197 times
      Been thanked: 145 times

      Absolutely! It’s a treat to see others who share my interests and age group (I’m coming up on 71). So, let’s be honest, ladies! Love, Kathryn!

    • #326893
      Falecia McGuire
      Participant
      Registered On: January 11, 2019
      Topics: 6
      Replies: 67
      Has thanked: 49 times
      Been thanked: 346 times

      The poll kind of got away on me before I could clarify.  I was not overly concerned with those who left things blank.  I was more concerned that the questions be more intuitive regarding the CD phenomenon.  I wouldn’t want anyone to be outed.  For example – I’ll make myself the guinea pig.

      • I have not gone out fully dressed for years.  I don’t know if I ever will again.  But I often go out dressed in totally female clothing items while presenting as a male.
      • At one point I used to do many household chores (cooking, cleaning, laundry, paying bills, yard work) either partially or completely dressed.  Now I do this only when I’m alone in the house – in the yard only when the neighbors are gone – because my wife wasn’t comfortable anymore.
      • I’m 72, started dressing at 13, got married at 25, began examining the why at 35, began to understand at 45, got married at (told her) 48, got comfortable at 52, developed the androgynous thing at 55, still slip into heels and a simple shift when alone at home.

      If we could encourage people to share their stories with better prompts, that would be my objective.  Maybe a continuum query?  We all have unique stories and yet our credibility lies in the patterns and cycles of our compulsion to wear feminine clothing.  It’s the commonality that helps us all cope with the uniqueness.  But there should be honesty.  If my wife read my posts, she would recognize me.  When you read my posts, you might recognize yourselves!

      FAM

    • #326891
      Rachel Williams
      Participant
      Registered On: November 3, 2019
      Topics: 2
      Replies: 79
      Has thanked: 124 times
      Been thanked: 182 times

      I’m 72, and I really want to know how old someone is.

      I am 72 also Jessica

      Rachel

      5 users thanked author for this post.
    • #326880
      Olivia Livin
      Participant
      Registered On: October 22, 2018
      Topics: 24
      Replies: 1152
      Has thanked: 3325 times
      Been thanked: 1795 times

      Hi Felicia

      Its true that it would be helpful to have more information on other members when we’re considering friendship requests or just finding common points for starting a conversation with someone. I attempt to do the latter even when I’m just looking to reply to a new member intro, I’ve been struggling as of late because a software glitch had made profiles non existent for me.

      BUT

      Consider the fact that many members are very deeply closeted and have a huge fear of discovery, however remote. For some it may have taken weeks to even get up the nerve to register on the site at all. Even when many do give information we have no idea of its accuracy, again partially to hide their true identity.

      I think that encouraging members to re-visit their profile info once they’ve become more comfortable with themselves and with the great supportive members here might be an idea. Updating that same info for those of us that have been members for a while would also be helpful, I have twice as things have progressed on my journey. Making the information mandatory would only serve to further scare away many potential good members that both gain and give much encouragement, or simply give useless and false information.

       

    • #326857
      Tiff Any
      Participant
      Registered On: June 1, 2019
      Topics: 0
      Replies: 634
      Has thanked: 1470 times
      Been thanked: 1181 times

      More detail certainly  helps me when considering a friend request or sending a request 💐💐

    • #326856
      Jessica Anderson
      Participant
      Registered On: August 18, 2019
      Topics: 3
      Replies: 235
      Has thanked: 314 times
      Been thanked: 513 times

      I’m 72, and I really want to know how old someone is.

    • #326848
      Diane
      Participant
      Registered On: August 6, 2018
      Topics: 20
      Replies: 177
      Has thanked: 104 times
      Been thanked: 388 times

      I couldn’t agree more, Falecia!

      One issue which you haven’t mentioned is the fact that profiles don’t currently have to be completed in full – most, if not all, questions should be mandatory.  So many members have completed (often only partially) the Name, About Me and Location sections but nothing else.  Incomplete profiles often give very little information about the new member upon which existing members can base requests for friendship.

      I think it would be very useful for a group to determine what information is needed, as a minimum, from prospective members before they can join CDH.  At risk of being little contentious (and I don’t want to upset anybody) perhaps existing members with incomplete profiles should be required to update them.

      Diane

Viewing 23 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from Crossdresser Heaven.

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Log in with your credentials

or    

Forgot your details?

Create Account